Sammy's Fish Box

  • 4.3
  • Seafood restaurant

Sammy’s Fish Box is a premier seafood restaurant located in the vibrant community of City Island, renowned for its fresh and delectable offerings. With a commitment to providing an exceptional dining experience, we pride ourselves on sourcing the finest seafood from local fishermen and sustainable suppliers. Our menu features a wide variety of dishes, from classic fried fish and shrimp to innovative seafood platters that highlight the rich flavors of the ocean. Each meal is expertly prepared by our skilled chefs, ensuring that every bite is a celebration of freshness and culinary excellence.

The inviting atmosphere at Sammy’s Fish Box makes it the perfect destination for families, friends, and seafood enthusiasts alike. Whether you’re dining indoors or enjoying the scenic views from our outdoor seating, our friendly staff is dedicated to providing top-notch service that complements your meal. Join us for an unforgettable seafood experience that captures the essence of City Island and leaves you craving more.

Brunch places you may also like

McKeon’s Bar and Restaurant is a charming Irish establishment located in the heart of Woodlawn, known for its warm atmosphere and authentic cuisine. With a commitment to delivering an exceptional dinin…

  • Irish restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn

Heritage Bar & Restaurant is a charming Irish establishment located in the heart of Woodlawn, where traditional Irish cuisine meets a warm, inviting atmosphere. With a commitment to quality and authenti…

  • Irish restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn
  • 503 reviews

Located in the heart of Woodlawn, our Irish Coffee Shop and Restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that embodies the spirit of Ireland. We pride ourselves on serving authentic Irish cuisine, crafte…

  • Irish restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn
  • 315 reviews

National Diner, located in the heart of Woodlawn, is a charming eatery that captures the essence of classic American dining. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, the diner offers a menu filled with a variety…

  • Diner
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn
  • 644 reviews

Webster Cafe & Diner is a charming establishment located in the heart of Woodlawn, where the warmth of community meets the comfort of classic diner cuisine. Our cozy atmosphere invites guests to unwind…

  • Diner
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn

Cafe Colonial Restaurant is a vibrant Latin American dining establishment nestled in the heart of Woodlawn. Known for its warm ambiance and welcoming atmosphere, the restaurant invites guests to experience t…

  • Latin American restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn

Sammy's Fish Box, City Island Photos

Sammy's Fish Box, City Island Reviews

  • Nicole Nicole

Consistently good food with generous portions. Food is well seasoned. Each table gets a starter with salad, garlic bread, a crusty loaf, cornbread and pickled vegetables. Service is fast and in addition to standard sides, yellow rice and corn on the cob are also served. Servers are pleasant. There will be enough leftovers for a hearty meal the next day. The bill will add up.

  • Danak D

I had dinner here with a group of family members recently and were seated at our reserved time at 6:15. We were waited on by Ahmad, who was very helpful, gracious, and accommodating. I was thoroughly surprised by the food portion!! It’s a good thing we didn’t order appetizers lol Our meals were paired with complimentary side of cornbread, bread roll with a slice of cheese, a small tray of olives, cauliflower and roasted bell pepper in a vinegar marinade as well as corn on the cob with yellow rice. In addition, we ate a standard salad with a choice of dressing. Like I mentioned earlier, food was plentiful and presented beautifully. Well fried, not overly greasy but bland in taste. If the batter that was used to fry the food were well seasoned, I would’ve been over the moon! Also, although shrimp were extra large, I dislike it when they aren’t de-veined. No amount of breading can hide that. The drinks were good, and we all had a great time.

  • Krammer Avillan

This is the about my fourth time coming here over the years, I keep coming back because of the very good service I get from the entrance to the waiter service and the family style food plating. My wife and I came and both ordered their famous fried jumbo shrimp that came with fries and coleslaw. Before hand we were served some garlic bread and some other very good cheese with another loaf of bread that had a crispy crust on the outside and warm and soft in the middle with a side order of drinks, I had a Long Island iced tea and she had a form of a piña colada mix with strawberry. Overall the food was very satisfying and very filling and I was able to bring some back home. Sammy’s is one of those places you can come on a date or with family and have a good meal and leave happy.

  • Own This Place?

Claim your listing and show customers you’re the real deal.

  • 41 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464
  • Cuisine Type: Seafood restaurant
  • Payment options: AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa

Places similar to Sammy's Fish Box

McKeon’s Bar and Restaurant is a charming Irish establishment located in the heart of Woodlawn, known for its warm atmosphere and authentic cuisine. With a commitment to delivering an exceptional dinin…

  • Irish restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn

Heritage Bar & Restaurant is a charming Irish establishment located in the heart of Woodlawn, where traditional Irish cuisine meets a warm, inviting atmosphere. With a commitment to quality and authenti…

  • Irish restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn
  • 503 reviews

Located in the heart of Woodlawn, our Irish Coffee Shop and Restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that embodies the spirit of Ireland. We pride ourselves on serving authentic Irish cuisine, crafte…

  • Irish restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn
  • 315 reviews

National Diner, located in the heart of Woodlawn, is a charming eatery that captures the essence of classic American dining. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, the diner offers a menu filled with a variety…

  • Diner
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn
  • 644 reviews

Webster Cafe & Diner is a charming establishment located in the heart of Woodlawn, where the warmth of community meets the comfort of classic diner cuisine. Our cozy atmosphere invites guests to unwind…

  • Diner
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn

Cafe Colonial Restaurant is a vibrant Latin American dining establishment nestled in the heart of Woodlawn. Known for its warm ambiance and welcoming atmosphere, the restaurant invites guests to experience t…

  • Latin American restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn
  • 865 reviews

Rambling House is a vibrant Irish pub located in the heart of Woodlawn, where tradition meets a warm, welcoming atmosphere. This establishment offers a genuine taste of Ireland, featuring an extensive select…

  • Irish pub
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Woodlawn

Sunrising Food Hut Restaurant & Bakery is a vibrant Jamaican dining establishment located in the heart of Williamsbridge. Our mission is to bring the rich and diverse flavors of Jamaican cuisine to the…

  • Jamaican restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Williamsbridge

Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant is a vibrant dining establishment located in the heart of Williamsbridge, specializing in authentic Caribbean cuisine. With a commitment to delivering the rich flavors and d…

  • Caribbean restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Williamsbridge
  • 38 reviews

Karahi King is a vibrant and inviting restaurant located in the heart of Williamsbridge, specializing in authentic South Asian cuisine. Our menu features a diverse array of dishes that celebrate the rich cul…

  • Restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Williamsbridge

Rocatone Seafood Restaurant is a vibrant culinary destination located in the heart of Williamsbridge, renowned for its authentic Jamaican flavors and fresh seafood offerings. With a commitment to quality and…

  • Jamaican restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Williamsbridge
  • 270 reviews

La Estrella Tropical is a vibrant Dominican restaurant located in the heart of Williamsbridge, offering an authentic taste of the Dominican Republic. Our establishment prides itself on serving traditional di…

  • Dominican restaurant
  • AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Williamsbridge